USCAA Men's Soccer All-American Winners
2025 | 2024 | 2023 | 2022 | 2021 | 2019 | 2018 | 2017 | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004
2025
| Division I First Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II First Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Tyriq Armstrong | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Mitch Cameron | Central Maine Community College | |
| Anthony Campos | Five Towns College | Ian Rathbun | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences | |
| Jose Garcia | Five Towns College | Dylan Withers | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |
| Thomas Bramwell | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Louis Sehr | Southern Maine Community College | |
| Antonio Costa | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Nathan Wiley | Paul Smith's College | |
| Moussa Cherif | Manor College | Raphael Cournoyer | Word of Life Bible Institute | |
| Ross Green | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Tim Eulenberger | Southern Maine Community College | |
| Filipe Ribeiro | Florida National University | Kenton Knox | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Sekou Sylla | Manor College | Matty Waters | Central Maine Community College | |
| Tajay Braham | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | Ignacio Ruiz Garcia | Southern Maine Community College | |
| Malik Cockings | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Jayson Ireland | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Daniel Valverde | Five Towns College | Finn Bethurum | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Juan Pugin | Florida National University | Jack Montesdeoca | Penn State Lehigh Valley | |
| Jallah Murvee | Manor College | Jack Cupitt | Penn State Lehigh Valley |
| Division I Second Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II Second Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Callum Judge | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Rodrigo Pedroza | Penn State Beaver | |
| Andre Hickling | Five Towns College | Eric Coria | Southwestern Adventist University | |
| Gino Burioni | North American University | Kane McDermott | Bucks County Community College | |
| Lucas Huertas | Atlantis University | Jaxon Olsen | Southern Maine Community College | |
| Steven Urbes | Berkeley College | Israel Pina | Southwestern Adventist University | |
| Jason Barrientos | Salem University | Trey Wynn | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |
| Geoffrey Owusu | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Isaac Melendez | Central Penn College | |
| Caleb Christner | Salem University | Alex Brown | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |
| Raynaldo St Bernard | Bloomfield College of Montclair State University | Massimo Di Pilato | Central Maine Community College | |
| Emil Gustafsson | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | Michael Vander Woude | Christendom College | |
| Christian Hernandez | Florida National University | Issiaka Thiama | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |
| Christopher Andrade | Berkeley College | Alija Korkutovic | Central Penn College | |
| Ahmad Hijaz | Salem University | Kagan Hance | Paul Smith's College | |
| Andrew Sherstnyov | Carlow University | Michael Meyers Jr. | Penn State Lehigh Valley |
| Division I Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | Division II Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | |
| Cj Branch | Salem University | Jacob Butler | Paul Smith's College | |
| Cameron Moag | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Yoan Theriault | Central Maine Community College | |
| Sebastine Daniel | Virginia State University | Gavin Martinez | Penn State York | |
| Yasser Rizki | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | Zack Wilcox | Penn State Schuylkill | |
| Aiden Holman | Manor College | Alex McAfee | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |
| Ethan Krystek | Penn State New Kensington | |||
| Brayden Otto | Bucks County Community College | |||
| Delvaughn Daley | NHTI - Concord’s Community College | |||
| Marcos Karasavas | Williamson College of the Trades | |||
| Mason Haffa | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |||
| Josh Garrison | Bucks County Community College | |||
| Chase Nederostek | Penn State Lehigh Valley | |||
| Nick Vander Woude | Christendom College |
2024
| Division I First Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II First Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Hector Ruiz | Five Towns College | Ivan Domingues | Central Maine Community College | |
| Jasen DeJesus | Berkeley College | Jeremiah Gomez | Central Maine Community College | |
| Francesco De Marco | Stanton University | Louis Sehr | Southern Maine Community College | |
| Aidan Marshall King | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Liam Curthoys | Paul Smith's College | |
| Alvaro Carrera-Aguirre | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Finn Bethurum | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Jadon Morgan | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Donnie Powell | Central Penn College | |
| Victor Batista | Berkeley College | Joseph Mathews | Word of Life Bible Institute | |
| Antonio Costa | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Jack Montesdeoca | Penn State Lehigh Valley | |
| Jhonny Zamor | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Colin Starr | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |
| Andre Hickling | Five Towns College | Chris Saboe-Moore | Central Penn College | |
| Jessie Kwasi | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Luke Johnson | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |
| Joseph Buel | Berkeley College | Chris Klinger | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |
| Archie Wisdom | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Ben Zimmerman | Penn State York | |
| Anthony Campos | Five Towns College | Ignacio Ruiz Garcia | Southern Maine Community College |
| Division I Second Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II Second Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Aldair Cardenas | Salem University | Sean Corcoran | Christendom College | |
| Chris Slater | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Thomas Oberholzer | Penn State Mont Alto | |
| Tomas Biasi | Lyon College | Raphael Cournoyer | Word of Life Bible Institute | |
| Ajay Chin | Unievrsity of Maine Fort Kent | Nick Grover | Paul Smith's College | |
| Aidan Byk | Bryant & Stratton - Buffalo | Max Whitson | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |
| Steven Urbes | Berkeley College | Fabrice Gatsinzi | Penn State Scranton | |
| Adan Crispin-Morales | Manor College | Vekaz Tihic | Penn State York | |
| Sebastian Cuenca | Five Towns College | Alfie Bashford | Central Maine Community College | |
| Erik Oliveira | Lyon College | Nathan Wiley | Paul Smith's College | |
| Aiden Holman | Manor College | Matt Wheaton | Central Penn College | |
| Victor Malaquias | Stanton University | Levi Morris | Bucks County Community College | |
| Loic Tinner | Stanton University | Kenton Knox | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Romeo Daniels | University of Maine Fort Kent | Dylan Shaw | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Jhonatan Moreno | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | Parker Davidson | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte |
| Division I Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | Division II Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | |
| Josh Hills | Salem University | Michael Meyers Jr. | Penn State Lehigh Valley | |
| Moussa Cherif | Manor College | Andrew Snyder | Christendom College | |
| Chaku Lubanda | Bryant & Stratton - Buffalo | Jonathan Illing | Williamson College of the Trades | |
| Juan Pugin | Florida National University | Jerod Younes | Penn State Lehigh Valley | |
| Ricardo Delwing | Florida National University | Sotir Agalliu | NHTI - Concord's Community College | |
| Hunter Brady | Carlow University | Gavin Martinez | Penn State York | |
| Justin Modeste | Bryant & Stratton - Buffalo | Cyleek Zaimoff | Word of Life Bible Institute | |
| Logan Gabriel | Penn State Beaver | |||
| Amani Byirinbiro | Penn State Scranton | |||
| Aiden Perry | Bucks County Community College | |||
| Eric Gonzalez | NHTI - Concord's Community College | |||
| Jared Perusich | Penn State Beaver | |||
| Sahil Arora | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences | |||
| James Melino | York County Community College | |||
| Grant Bernstein | Central Penn College | |||
| Mason Haffa | Penn State Greater Allegheny |
2023
| Division I First Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II First Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| James Hogan | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Chris Manful | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Jadon Morgan | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Jacob Philippe | Central Penn College | |
| Issac Bourne | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Ivan Domingues | Central Maine Community College | |
| Eddie Fortescue Jr. | Manor College | Suad Lukovic | Berkeley College | |
| Ajay Chin | University of Maine Fort Kent | Devin Murray | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Renato Filho | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Victor Batista | Berkeley College | |
| Andrei Galca | Lyon College | Adam Youssef | Central Penn College | |
| Jamie Ward | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Elijah DeBooth | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Collin Gentle | Shaw University | Raymond Kelly | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Shawn Altidor Viau | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Robert Bettencourt | SUNY-ESF | |
| Cheva Denton | University of Maine Fort Kent | Dylan Luong | Central Penn College | |
| Antonio Costa | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Brandon Cairy | Williamson College of the Trades | |
| Jhonatan Moreno | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | Tyler Van Kirk | Penn State Beaver | |
| Konner Sayre | Carlow University | Angel Chavez | Five Towns College |
| Division I Second Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II Second Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Erik Olivera | Lyon College | Jay Carlson | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences | |
| Michael German | University of Maine Fort Kent | Zachary Bosak | Williamson College of the Trades | |
| Gavin Moore | Carlow University | Sean Corcoran | Christendom College | |
| Andrea Fincato | Salem University | Joseph Mathews | Word of Life Bible Institute | |
| Ronaldo Jacob | Lyon College | Carsen Cyr | Southern Maine Community College | |
| Kevin Garcia | Carlow University | Ethan Hutcherson | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Mohamed Kajtazi | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | Anthony Campos | Five Towns College | |
| Diego Losada | Salem University | Colin Starr | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |
| Jhonny Zamor | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Ordi Bimvy | Central Maine Community College | |
| Aidan Byk | Bryant & Stratton - Buffalo | Sahil Arora | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences | |
| Justin Modeste | Bryant & Stratton - Buffalo | Andre Hickling | Five Towns College | |
| Francisco Crimi | Florida National University | Finn Bethurum | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Vinicius Mallmann | Florida National University | Jordi Ronal Ambrojo-Uceta | Bucks County Community College | |
| Romeo Daniels | University of Maine Fort Kent | Lucas Zuleta | Berkeley College |
| Division I Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | Division II Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | |
| Aidan McGeown | Lyon College | Calem Mason | Word of Life Bible Institute | |
| Jaheim Grey | Bryant & Stratton - Buffalo | Chris Klinger | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |
| Ben Lam | Salem University | Nick Grover | Paul Smith's College | |
| Kevin Williams | Bryant & Stratton - Buffalo | Alex McAfee | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |
| Mason Kovach | Carlow University | Andrew Fanelli | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |
| Lucas Lesh | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |||
| Peter Agelis | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |||
| Igor Domingues | Central Maine Community College | |||
| Angelo Paniagua | Penn State Hazleton | |||
| William Perry | Southern Maine Community College | |||
| Andrew Swaisgood | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |||
| Issa Doumbia | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |||
| Christian Zavala | Penn State Brandywine | |||
| Michael Chaloupka | Penn State New Kensington | |||
| Alija Korkutovic | Central Penn College | |||
| Ethan Paxton | Penn State Beaver |
2022
| Division I First Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II First Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| John Amoah | University of Maine Fort Kent | Chris Manful | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Eddie Fortescue Jr. | Manor College | Angel Chavez | Five Towns College | |
| Shawn Altidor Viau | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Josiah Davis | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |
| Adil Iggoute | University of Maine Fort Kent | Raymond Kelly | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Kevon Maitland | University of Maine Fort Kent | Alex McAfee | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |
| Hagan Roberts | Mississippi University for Women | Erson Gerbeshi | Berkeley College | |
| Felipe Pampolim | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Jaeger James | Central Penn College | |
| Jarrett Williams | Paul Quinn College | Noel Diaz | Paul Smith's College | |
| Renato Filho | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Alex Davidson | Berkeley College | |
| Aaron Boateng | University of Maine Fort Kent | Dawid Mroz | Berkeley College | |
| Giovanni Gallina | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Steven Paguada | Five Towns College | |
| Jose Vazquez | Paul Quinn College | Jake Philippe | Central Penn College | |
| Janvier Ramson | Carlow University | Liam Menz | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |
| Graham Rodney | Mississippi University for Women | Osarumwense Ehigiamusoe | Penn State Beaver |
| Division I Second Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II Second Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Jacob Vickers | Mississippi University for Women | Steven Donnelly | Paul Smith's College | |
| Felipe Santos | D'Youville College | Joe Madigan | Christendom College | |
| Aiden Holman | Manor College | Isaiah Soto | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |
| Wissem Obeid | Shaw University | Jerod Younes | Penn State Lehigh Valley | |
| Ben Zuhlke | Shaw University | Nadeem Shakshir | Penn State Beaver | |
| Jonathan Hernandez | Paul Quinn College | Austin Arnold | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Sudesh Tiwari | Carlow University | Jacob Guerrini | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Kevin Garcia | Carlow University | Kyle Reuter | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Ben Lam | Salem University | Brandon Cairy | Williamson College of the Trades | |
| Isaac Bourne | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Raphael Cournoyer | Word of Life Bible Institute | |
| Keigan Young | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Michael Mogollon | Berkeley College | |
| Vinicius Mallmann | Florida National University | Nima Bahrami | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Arthur Da Silva | D'Youville College | Amson Charleston | Central Penn College | |
| Archie Cooke | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Tim Romero | Paul Smith's College |
| Division I Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | Division II Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | |
| Victor Ruiz | Florida National University | Lex Smith | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Marcos Bakale | Florida National University | Abdifatah Yussuf | Central Maine Community College | |
| Roberto Dominguez | Paul Quinn College | Jacob Fetterman | Penn State Lehigh Valley | |
| Martin Marijuan | Florida National University | Kaiden Farrar | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |
| Tres Ray | Mississippi University for Women | Sean Corcoran | Christendom College | |
| Ethan Picard | D'Youville College | Sahil Arora | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences | |
| James Hogan | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | River Terry | Penn State Mont Alto | |
| Ruben Pjilman | Salem University | Oleksandr Bruno | Central Maine Community College | |
| Diaje' Hart | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |||
| Issiaka Thiama | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |||
| Antonino Terranova | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |||
| Cameron Downey | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |||
| Bryce Dalpiaz | Penn State Hazleton | |||
| Jaden Haig | Bucks County Community College | |||
| Hector Ruiz | Five Towns College | |||
| Jordan Cooper | Penn State New Kensington | |||
| Chris Klinger | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |||
| Laszlo Dorogi | Southern Maine Community College | |||
| Troy Ingham | SUNY-ESF |
2021
| Division I First Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II First Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Adil Iggoute | University of Maine Fort Kent | Angel Chavez | Five Towns College | |
| Aaron Boateng | University of Maine Fort Kent | Alex Sydor | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Hamza Zagmouzi | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Jacob Guerrini | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Junior Gomez Depina | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | Suab Nur | Central Maine Community College | |
| Levyn Benevides | Paul Quinn College | Steven Paguada | Five Towns College | |
| Babucarr Ceesay | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Mark LaRochelle | Christendom College | |
| Nick Dumond | D'Youville College | Salaimon Sarwari | Berkeley College | |
| Jhonatan Moreno | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | Esteban Pedrueza | Berkeley College | |
| Roberto Dominguez | Paul Quinn College | Marvis Nosa | Paul Smith's College | |
| Kyle Rodriguez | Mississippi University for Women | Sebastian Gomez | Five Towns College | |
| Yago Pimenta | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Cadeyn Muthard | Penn State Lehigh Valley | |
| Ronaldo Watson | University of Maine Fort Kent | Ben Oldham | The King's College (NY) | |
| Luca Natale | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Eduardo Castro | Southwestern Adventist University | |
| Vini Lopes | Mississippi University for Women | JJ Farbes | Penn State Wilkes-Barre |
| Division I Second Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II Second Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Rolph Miot | Manor College | Eriksen Shea | Southern Maine Community College | |
| Juan Parra | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Brady Braun | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Patrick Palmer | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | Steven Donnelly | Paul Smith's College | |
| Janvier Ramson | Carlow University | Conner Geis | Penn State Mont Alto | |
| Felipe Pampolim | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Anthony Campos | Five Towns College | |
| Andrew Aceituno | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Brandon Greene | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |
| Jacob Vickers | Mississippi University for Women | Joey Cairy | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Jarrett Williams | Paul Quinn College | Erick Carabantes | Berkeley College | |
| Pedro Ivaskoski | University of Maine Fort Kent | Elijah DeBooth | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Henry Estrada | Paul Quinn College | Mishael Garcia | Penn State Beaver | |
| Luis Felipe Santos | D'Youville College | Stephane Mendoza | Word of Life Bible Institute | |
| Blas Barrancos | Florida National University | John Cupitt | Penn State Lehigh Valley | |
| Jonathan Ventura-Garcia | Manor College | John Sanders | SUNY-ESF | |
| Issac Bourne | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Marcos Cabral | The King's College (NY) |
| Division I Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | Division II Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | |
| Tomas Casavilla | Florida National University | Nadeem Shakshir | Penn State Beaver | |
| Constantino Higa | Florida National University | Jake Ross | Penn State Beaver | |
| Rodrigo Festuccia | Florida National University | Juan Josue Rodriguez | Berkeley College | |
| Chase Reynolds | University of Dallas | Jack Phillips | SUNY-ESF | |
| Adam Boor | Bryant & Stratton - Rochester | Jacob Lingerman | Word of Life Bible Institute | |
| Terrell Johnson | Mississippi University for Women | Jack Montesdeoca | Penn State Lehigh Valley | |
| Noah Steele | D'Youville College | Austin Arnold | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Brandon Cairy | Williamson College of the Trades | |||
| Stuart Dare | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |||
| Andrew Pettica | Williamson College of the Trades | |||
| Logan Vega | Southwestern Adventist University | |||
| Chris Klinger | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |||
| Andrew Bollinger | Penn State Beaver | |||
| Raymond Kelly | Penn State Brandywine |
2020
*No Championship Events due to COVID-19.
2019
| Division I First Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II First Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Aaron Boateng | University of Maine Fort Kent | Axel Ayllon-Ortiz | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Connor McGoldrick | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Ilijah Washington | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |
| Francisco Bongiovanni | Florida National University | Alberto Olivas-Vazquez | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |
| Yago Pimenta | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Gennaro Vittorioso | Berkeley College | |
| Travar McCulloch | University of Maine Fort Kent | Patrick Kiely | Williamson College of the Trades | |
| Nickalous Gayle | University of Maine Fort Kent | Mohamed Matan | Southern Maine Community College | |
| Manuel Villegas | Florida National University | Amadou Sy | Berkeley College | |
| Yazen Bakhrebah | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Marcos Hidalgo | Berkeley College | |
| Babucarr Ceesay | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Dario Cruz-Sepulveda | Berkeley College | |
| Glenroy Osbourne | University of Maine Fort Kent | Joshua Nagle | Southern Maine Community College | |
| Omar Abdallah Nabilsi | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Danylo Yakymov | Penn State Beaver | |
| Edson Alvadrado | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Jean-Gardy Derineau | Berkeley College | |
| Sebastian Mendez | Paul Quinn College | Edvin Loefgren | The King's College | |
| Emilie Amouzou | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Jalen Hjelmeng | University of Cincinnati - Clermont |
| Division I Second Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II Second Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Julio Hernandez | Paul Quinn College | Ian Foote | SUNY ESF | |
| Martin Marijuan | Florida National University | Benjamin Elvenes | Berkeley College | |
| Francisco Vilanueva | Washington Adventist University | Ian Roland | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Noah Bryant | Mid-Atlantic Christian University | Darrio Gilmore | Penn State Beaver | |
| Brody Rettle | SUNY Delhi | TJ Manning | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |
| Levyn Benavides | Paul Quinn College | Mishael Garcia | Penn State Beaver | |
| Lucas Moreira | Washington Adventist University | Fiston Kapongo | NHTI | |
| Hunter Haughland | University of Dallas | Keto Tchiputo | Southern Maine Community College | |
| Rodrigo Festuccia | Florida National University | Robert Parker | Berkeley College | |
| Keaton Krischak | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Cassidy Kelly | University of Cincinnati - Clermont | |
| Daniel Moreira | Washington Adventist University | Brady Braun | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Paulo Correia | Dean College | Will Feehan | Warren Wilson College | |
| Chase Reynolds | University of Dallas | Jack Watters | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |
| Brady McNamara | University of Dallas | Mickael Myagkota | SUNY ESF |
| Division I Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | Division II Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | |
| Evan Luck | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | Isaac Whitenight | Penn State Hazleton | |
| Jake Buete | University of Dallas | Alexander Thompson | Central Maine Community College | |
| Kyle Lamb | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | Salaimon Sarwari | Berkeley College | |
| Corey O'Toole | SUNY Delhi | Tyler Skaer | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Nate Getman | Bryant & Stratton - Albany | RJ Long | Penn State Beaver | |
| Bryce Antoch | Dean College | Carlos Colindres | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Juan Velez | SUNY Delhi | Soudiane Issoufou | Central Penn College | |
| Mathurin Allawai | University of Valley Forge | Mark LaRochelle | Christendom College | |
| Alex Lopez | Penn State Brandywine | |||
| Adrian Santos | Five Towns College | |||
| Carmine Tronolone | SUNY ESF | |||
| Joshua Zakrzewski | Penn State New Kensington | |||
| Ricky Wooditch | Penn State Wilkes-Barre | |||
| William Rivera | Five Towns College | |||
| Nicholas Foeckler | Christendom College | |||
| Josiah Simons | The King's College (NY) | |||
| Zach Savage | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |||
| Adrian Wong | Five Towns College |
2018 (First year men's soccer went divisional)
| Division I First Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II First Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Shawn Genus | University of Maine Fort Kent | Pete Day | Christendom College | |
| Groutchov Pierre | Florida College | Spencer Smith | The King's College (NY) | |
| Uros Momic | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Danylo Yakymov | Penn State Beaver | |
| Romaine Williamson | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Alhasane Sako | SUNY-Delhi | |
| Hector Aguirre | Cleary University | Edvin Loefgren | The King's College (NY) | |
| Chase Reynolds | University of Dallas | Phil Hepburn | Vermont Tech | |
| Rodrigo Costa | Florida National University | Cooper Weinman | SUNY-ESF | |
| Davinson Mera | Florida College | Daniel Willie | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Milan Jakoviljevic | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | JT Fucci | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |
| Sean Taylor | University of Dallas | Edward Ahanmisi | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences | |
| Kyle Mcgibbons | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse | Stefan Correia | SUNY-Delhi | |
| Mattia Moggia | Cleary University | James Cellucci | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Rodrigo Festuccia | Florida National University | Julio Pena | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte | |
| Felipe Campos | Dean College | Camden Labrecque | Southern Maine Community College |
| Division I Second Team All-Americans | Institution | Division II Second Team All-Americans | Institution | |
| Sean Carlin | University of Dallas | Mohamed Camara | Penn State Brandywine | |
| Travar Mccollah | University of Maine Fort Kent | James Foeckler | Christendom College | |
| Pedro Veiga | Florida National University | Geoffrey Smith | The Crown College | |
| Sorel St Fleur | Florida College | Noah Keith | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences | |
| Josh Almeida | Cleary University | Belmo Nurkic | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |
| Daniel Moreira | Washington Adventist University | Kyle King | Paul Smith's College | |
| Rodney Witter | University of Maine Fort Kent | Andrew Perenic | Penn State New Kensington | |
| Kristopher Ospina | Florida College | Mikell McKenzie | Vermont Tech | |
| Andrew Ciancone | University of Dallas | Idriss Benjelloun | Penn State Greater Allegheny | |
| Miguel Barnaby | University of Maine Fort Kent | Mark Weinert | The Crown College | |
| Stefone Coburn | Washington Adventist University | Josue Jimenez | Berkeley College | |
| Janvier Ramson | Carlow University | Nicholas Van Bennekum | SUNY-ESF | |
| Benjamin Delage | Cleary University | Marcos Andrino | SUNY-Delhi | |
| Andrew Aceituno | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Carmine Tronolone | SUNY-ESF | |
| Mo Baskaron | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte |
| Division I Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | Division II Honorable Mention All-Americans | Institution | |
| - | - | Blaise Masumbuko | NHTI | |
| - | - | Luke Myers | Williamson College of the Trades | |
| - | - | Brody Rettle | SUNY Delhi | |
| - | - | Wender Lima | Berkeley College | |
| - | - | Brandon Crochunis | Penn State Brandywine | |
| - | - | Jean-Gardy Derineau | Berkeley College | |
| - | - | Aaron Wrobleski | Penn State Hazleton | |
| - | - | Dave Mattern | Vermont Tech | |
| - | - | Luke Day | SUNY-ESF | |
| - | - | Denis Moshchenko | Vaughn College | |
| - | - | Jostin Sarmiento | SUNY Delhi | |
| - | - | Easton Colbert | The Crown College | |
| - | - | Andre Sturgeon | NHTI | |
| - | - | Dario Cruz Sepulveda | Berkeley College |
2017
First Team All-Americans
| Kristopher Ospina | Florida College |
| Milan Jakovljevic | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Amani Francois | College of St. Joseph (VT) |
| Jalen Jackson | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte |
| Mattieu LeRoux | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Rodrigo Costa | Florida National University |
| Austin McDaniel | Florida College |
| Sean Carlin | University of Dallas |
| Felipe Campos | Dean College |
| Noah Keith | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences |
| Groutchov Pierre | Florida College |
| Mark Parchment | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Rodney Witter | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Miguel Barnaby | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Sam Fannings | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte |
Second Team All-Americans
| Zino Zampach | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Hector Aguirre | Cleary University |
| Noah Kwortnik | Illinois Tech |
| Weeb Isaac | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte |
| Mina Girgis | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences |
| Rosyvelt Baessa | College of St. Joseph (VT) |
| Meshema Charles | Berkeley College |
| Gregorio Calvillo | Florida College |
| Felix Piazzo | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| John Lowes | Johnson & Wales University - Charlotte |
| Alex Gordonbeck | Dean College |
| Rajbir Lohat | Penn State Brandywine |
| Joseph Kulikowski | SUNY-ESF |
| Odean Irons | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Pepe Vieira | Dean College |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Noah Schneider | Cleary University |
| Jack Hanlon | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciencesf |
| Haidar Al-Freihy | University of Maine Machias |
| Pascal Bikanura | Penn State New Kensington |
| Geoffrey Smith | The Crown College |
| Chris Riebman | Penn State Brandywine |
| Moussa Diouf | Penn State Hazleton |
| Pete Day | Christendom College |
| Lorenzo Segura | University of Maine Machias |
| Nat Kajiwara | University of Dallas |
| Luke Day | SUNY-ESF |
| Shabthai Abellard | Berkeley College |
| Hassane Camara | Berkeley College |
| Nathan Silveira | Dean College |
| Matt Houlihan | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences |
| Keven Andrade | College of St. Joseph (VT) |
| Geoff Golick | SUNY-ESF |
| Brandon Bortei-Doku | Illinois Tech |
| Alhasane Sako | SUNY Delhi |
2016
First Team All-Americans
| Dennis Ntsin | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Allen Harasimiuk | Florida College |
| Milan Jakovljevic | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Joseph O'Halloran | SUNY Delhi |
| Ben Kluvers | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Bill Walleekendeh | Penn State Brandywine |
| Gregorio Calvillo | Florida College |
| Stefan Petricevic | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Ahkeim Forbes | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Austin McDaniel | Florida College |
| Leandro Alves (Geo) | Dean College |
| Ali Dawha | Berkeley College |
| Kyle Venditti | Penn State Hazleton |
| Odean Irons | University of Maine Fort Kent |
Second Team All-Americans
| Matheus Eccard | Florida National University |
| James Cellucci | Penn State Brandywine |
| Eitan Kiin | SUNY-ESF |
| Jonathan Krek | Florida College |
| Stanley Benjamin | Concordia College (AL) |
2015
First Team All-Americans
| Ben Kluvers | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Butch Forbes | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Erickson Alves | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Stanley Benjamin | Concordia College (AL) |
| Willie Monthe | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Lewis Lacy | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Tanner Richardson | Florida College |
| Drew Lytton | WVU Tech |
| Francisco Neto | WVU Tech |
| Jorge Guarin | SUNY-ESF |
| Dennis Ntsin | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Paul Ambrose | Penn State York |
| Ross Downie | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Raul Martin | WVU Tech |
Second Team All-Americans
| Romario Georgis | Rochester College |
| Zak Giorgi | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences |
| Trevor Holdridge | SUNY Delhi |
| Marcus Smith | Penn State Beaver |
| Steve Miller | Penn State York |
| Haakon Schjelderup | Berkeley College |
| Thoby Wendy | Concordia College (AL) |
| Johann Hermiz | Rochester College |
| Brad Camenisch | Berea College |
| Jonathan Thompson | Florida College |
| Nick Oliveria | SUNY Delhi |
| Kevin Beaton | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Berni Michaud | Concordia College (AL) |
| Drew Martin | Southern Maine Community College |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Fred Prest | Rochester College |
| Victor Marotta | Berkeley College |
| Bill Walleekendeh | Penn State Brandywine |
| Kyle Venditti | Penn State Hazleton |
| Mitchell Porter | Alfred State College |
| Jack Hanlon | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences |
| Jose Segarra | WVU Tech |
| Ricardo Dip | Penn State Greater Allegheny |
| Haidar Al-Freihy | University of Maine Machias |
| Yannick Mabuye | Berkeley College |
| Robert Devone | University of Maine Machias |
| Phillip Hepburn | Vermont Tech |
| Eitan Kiin | SUNY-ESF |
| Julius Illiano | Penn State Beaver |
| Noah Griffith | Illinois Tech |
| James Cellucci | Penn State Brandywine |
2014
First Team All-Americans
| Craig Mitchell | WVU Tech |
| Phil Dionne | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Dan Mcgraw | SUNY-ESF |
| Jack Ball | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Sean Latimer | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Alex Pastor | WVU Tech |
| Ben Kluvers | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Willie Monthe | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Hunter Moles | WVU Tech |
| Hector Guerrero | Penn College |
| Juan Suarez | WVU Tech |
| Brahadon Ramirez | Illinois Tech |
| Erickson Alves | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Kennard Brown | University of Maine Fort Kent |
Second Team All-Americans
| Rex Meier | Illinois Tech |
| Asri Bruce | University of Maine Machias |
| Berni Michaud | Concordia College (AL) |
| Haakon Schjelderup | Berkeley College |
| Nick Escalante | SUNY Canton |
| Will Salta | NHTI |
| Kyle Bardwell | SUNY-ESF |
| Yussuf Olajide | Bryant & Stratton - Syracuse |
| Matt Daddario | Daemen College |
| Fredy Mendoza | Concordia College (AL) |
| Samir Sandzic | NHTI |
| Daniel Seargeant | Rochester College |
| Hermes Toska | Cleary University |
| Cole Beale | Daemen College |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Robert Ralyea | Daemen College |
| Alex Roache | Paul Smith's College |
| Taylor Young | Paul Smith's College |
| Joey Beshara | Rochester College |
| Bill Walleekendeh | Penn State Brandywine |
| Danilo Silva | Concordia College (AL) |
| David Castillo | Florida College |
| Austin Petty | Cleary University |
| Juan Solares | University of Maine Machias |
| Blair Moore | Cleary University |
| Tyler Gray | Southern State Community College |
| Diego Outeiral | Concordia College (AL) |
| Hunter Mowery | SUNY Canton |
| Payton Anderson | Florida College |
| Bryan Costa | Berkeley College |
2013
First Team All-Americans
| Ben Kluvers | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Giancarlo Luna | Briarcliffe College |
| Joe Jackson | WVU Tech |
| Tyler Fabian | WVU Tech |
| Dennis Fuerst | WVU Tech |
| Kennard Brown | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Alan Acevedo | Briarcliffe College |
| Philippe Dionne | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Jamie Reid | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Olaff Alexis Mina | University of Maine Machias |
| Cesar Acosta | Lindenwood University - Belleville |
| Joey Beshara | Rochester College |
| Jad El-Zein | Marygrove College |
| Steve Rathbun | Paul Smith's College |
| Christopher Brennan | Penn College |
Second Team All-Americans
| Ramiro Osorio | NHTI |
| Tyler Troup | University of Maine Machias |
| Daniel Seargeant | Rochester College |
| Johan Sundberg | Lindenwood University - Belleville |
| Julio Zaldivar | Lindenwood University - Belleville |
| Haakon Schjelderup | Berkeley College |
| Leandro Placido | Briarcliffe College |
| Ryan Little | Paul Smith's College |
| Abdoulie Jallow | Marygrove College |
| Johan Fastberg | Unity College |
| Kyle Clifford | Daemen College |
| Alex Roache | Paul Smith's College |
| Kyle Siegel | SUNY-ESF |
| Tim VanderWoude | Christendom College |
| Nick Escalante | SUNY Canton |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Alfredo Palacios | University of Maine Machias |
| Dare Aniyikaye | Berkeley College |
| Abanda Nkwanyou | Washington Adventist University |
| Justin Kane | Rochester College |
| Buba Minteh | Lindenwood University - Belleville |
| Nate Hicklin | Rochester College |
| Miguel CiFuentes | Briarcliffe College |
| Raul Martin | WVU Tech |
| Johnny Foeckler | Christendom College |
| Derek Healy | University of Maine Presque Isle |
| Luke Mcfalls | Penn College |
| Zach Hecox | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences |
| Tyler Gallagher | SUNY Canton |
| Taylor Young | Paul Smith's College |
| Tyler Gray | Southern State Community College |
| Abdulai Jagana | SUNY Canton |
| Jonathan Fioramonti | Christendom College |
| Sean O'Donnell | Williamson College of the Trades |
| Marcus Smith | Penn State Beaver |
| Trey Chilcoat | Penn State York |
| Paul Ambrose | Penn State York |
2012
First Team All-Americans
| Rodrigo Manzanares | WVU Tech |
| Kennard Brown | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Joseph Jackson | WVU Tech |
| Jarryd Phillips | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Tyler Troup | University of Maine Machias |
| Adam Freeman | Southern Virginia University |
| Vincent Mitchell | Concordia College (AL) |
| Kyle Siegel | SUNY ESF |
| Kevin Dionne | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Craig Mitchell | WVU Tech |
| Steve Tyrrell | SUNY ESF |
| Ryan Foster | Southern Virginia University |
| Giovanni Sinclair | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Christian Bashios | NHTI |
| John Dunn | WVU Tech |
Second Team All-Americans
| William Banahene | SUNY Canton |
| Kristopher Asmus | Ohio Mid-Western College |
| Branden Seeberger | Southern Virginia University |
| Chris Hummel | Penn State Hazleton |
| Joey Killion | University of Dallas |
| Zac MCCulloch | Southern Virginia University |
| Jordan Berry | Marygrove College |
| Tyler Blake | Penn State Beaver |
| Christopher Brennan | Penn College |
| Trevor Carignan | NHTI |
| Ben Shade | Penn College |
| Kyle Venditti | Penn State Hazleton |
| Troy Bacchus | Concordia College (AL) |
| Ryan Graig | SUNY ESF |
| Kyle Bardwell | SUNY ESF |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Abdoullie Jallow | Marygrove College |
| Luis Carlow | Concordia College (AL) |
| Kyle Ehlers | Southern Maine Community College |
| Ramon Arce | Berkeley College |
| Daniel Caballero | Lindenwood University - Belleville |
| Caio De Costa | Iowa Wesleyan College |
| Peter Dore | Southern Maine Community College |
| Zach Hecox | Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences |
| Chad Helberg | Rochester College |
| Christopher Matthews | Iowa Wesleyan College |
| Frank Zeba | University of Maine Machias |
| Olaff Alexis Mina | University of Maine Machias |
| Shenaldo Parks | Concordia College (AL) |
| Phil Bair | Penn College |
| Leighton Richards | Concordia College (AL) |
| Luis Herrera | University of Maine Machias |
| Ryan St. John | Rochester College |
2011
First Team All-Americans
| Tyler Jimison | Southern State Community College |
| Alejandro Lopez | Lindenwood University - Belleville |
| Phathizwe Sacolo | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Keith Williams | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Luis Morfin | Lindenwood University - Belleville |
| Nathan Rollyson | Southern State Community College |
| Blais Whitney | Southern Maine Community College |
| Aldin Avdic | Penn State York |
| Trey Chilcoat | Penn State York |
| Jim Kallrakal | Penn State Brandywine |
| Matt Hessling | Ohio Mid-Western College |
| Spencer Jacoby | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Nick Link | Southern Maine Community College |
| Wyatt Chaney | Southern State Community College |
| David Girouard | University of Maine Fort Kent |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Chris Brennan | Penn College |
| Tim Cook | Southern State Community College |
| Nate Dant | Unity College |
| Adam Beck | Penn State York |
| Jordan Berry | Marygrove College |
| William DeAngelo | Penn College |
| Luke Dillenburger | Ohio Mid-Western College |
| Tyler Houck | Lindenwood University - Belleville |
| David Mugenga | Berkeley College |
| Nemanja Nenadovic | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Alex Steele | Penn State Brandywine |
| Kris Wignes | University of Maine Machias |
| Stefan Zaluckey | University of Maine Machias |
| Mario Black | Ave Maria University |
| Shane Powell | SUNY Canton |
| Kevin Nateras | Walla Walla University |
| Dan Brinkley | Penn State York |
| Craig Maffei | University of Maine Presque Isle |
| David Barker | Florida College |
| Luis Herrera | University of Maine Machias |
2010
First Team All-Americans
| Andre Anderson | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Jordan Berry | Marygrove College |
| Tyler Blake | Penn State Beaver |
| Oscar Corado | Briarcliffe College |
| Chuvalos George | Concordia College (AL) |
| David Girouard | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Erik Gutierrez | Washington Adventist University |
| Tyler Jimison | Southern State Community College |
| Dakota Letendre | NHTI |
| Nick Link | Southern Maine Community College |
| David Panchano | Briarcliffe College |
| Daniel Rodriguez | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Nathan Rollyson | Southern State Community College |
| Daniele Stabile | Lindenwood University—Belleville |
| Keith Williams | University of Maine Fort Kent |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Messanvi Aboussa | NHTI |
| Chris Brennan | Penn College of Technology |
| Barrington Blake | University of Maine Fort Kent |
| Hyron Brown—Baptiste | Concordia College (AL) |
| Chase Burns | Southern State Community College |
| Robert Ekrem | Rochester College |
| Tyler Houck | Lindenwood University—Belleville |
| Joey Killion | University of Dallas |
| Lekol Kordah | Concordia College (AL) |
| Ryan Meske | University of Dallas |
| Nemanja Nenadovic | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Brent Pierre | Concordia College (AL) |
| Sunkung Sillah | Briarcliffe College |
| Tristan Smith | Penn College of Technology |
| Jad El—Zein | Marygrove College |
2009
First Team All-Americans
| Messanvi Aboussa | NHTI |
| Aldin Avdic | Penn State York |
| Hyron Brown-Baptiste | Concordia College (AL) |
| Bryant Constantine | Concordia College (AL) |
| Ronny Golcavez | Briarcliffe College |
| Kwame Kreme | Washington Adventist University |
| Tim Krohn | Penn State York |
| Steve Miller | Penn State York |
| Peter Nelson | Rochester College |
| David Panchano | Briarcliffe College |
| Nick Papamichael | NHTI |
| Se-Eun Park | Washington Adventist University |
| Justin Robbins | Spalding University |
| Juan Zuluaga | Briarcliffe College |
| Dakota Letendre GK* | NHTI |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Chris Gerhardt | Rochester College |
| Justin Shaffer | Penn State York |
| Jordan Berry | Marygrove College |
| Tyler Blake | Penn State Beaver |
| Emery Joyeau | Concordia College (AL) |
| Steve Bullock | Penn College |
| Kristopher Duff | Southern State Community College |
| Luke Ireland | Northern Maine Community College |
| Alejandro Lopez | Lindenwood University—Belleville |
| Francisco Osegueda | Southern Virginia University |
| Brent Pierre | Concordia College (AL) |
| Nick Platipodis | Robert Morris University - Springfield |
| Daniele Stabile | Lindenwood University—Belleville |
| Geoff Stenger | Spalding University |
| Will Van Nostrand | Spalding University |
| John Wineland | Rochester College |
| Brett Buffington GK* | Warren Wilson College |
| Coleby Frye | Penn College |
2008
First Team All-Americans
| Alan Acevedo | Briarcliffe College |
| Kouame Kreme | Columbia Union College |
| Nicholas Papamichael | NHTI |
| Antonio Bifsha | NHTI |
| Luke Ireland | Northern Maine Community College |
| Stephen Lis | Penn College |
| Suhaib Alqaddomi | Penn State York |
| Tim Krohn | Penn State York |
| Ibrahim Foryoh | Rochester College |
| Chris Hall | Rochester College |
| Daniel Rodriguez | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Lorenza Stephens | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Justin Shaeffer | Penn State York |
| Sam Petrie | Northern Maine Community College |
| Alex Flores | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Colby Frye | Penn College |
| Jorge De La Fuenta | Robert Morris University - Springfield |
| Josh Smith | NHTI |
| Steve Bull | Penn College |
| Shane Hurdle | Central Maine Community College |
| Cory Anderson | Penn State Beaver |
| Todd Long | Penn State Beaver |
| Ben Suarez | Penn State York |
| Dave Ristich | Rochester College |
| Kristopher Duff | Southern State Community College |
| Shane Belmont | Southern Virginia University |
| Greg McClain | Southern Virginia University |
| Misael Andrade | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Jonthan Uribe | Columbia Union College |
| Cameron Fertenbaugh | Penn State Beaver |
2007
First Team All-Americans
| Sevy Price | Southern Virginia University |
| Se Eun Park | Columbia Union College |
| Nathaniel Oyefeso | Columbia Union College |
| Preston Buechler | Presentation College |
| Cody Becker | Presentation College |
| Gerardo Mejia | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Scott Malagon | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| John Perez | Robert Morris University - Springfield |
| Calvin Marshall | Rochester College |
| Chris Hall | Rochester College |
| Ben Nelson | Rochester College |
| Ben Lomeri | Southern Maine Community College |
| Davonion Foster | Columbia Union College |
| Alex Flores | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Dave Ristich | Rochester College |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| John Broek | NHTI |
| Josh Smith | NHTI |
| Jordan Heupel | Presentation College |
| Ian Valasquez | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Ryan Patrick | Southern State Community College |
| Dominique Hunt | Walla Walla University |
| Luke Bernard | Warren Wilson College |
| Brandon Dyrkacz | NHTI |
| Philimon Tudor | Walla Walla University |
| Jorge Fernandez | Walla Walla University |
2006
First Team All-Americans
| Brandon Jackson | Taylor University - Ft. Wayne |
| Josh Hickey | Rochester College |
| Nick Squires | NHTI |
| Greg Erickson | Northwest Christian College |
| Evan Ormand | Presentation College |
| Collin Huepel | Presentation College |
| Sevy Price | Southern Virginia University |
| Scottie Malagon | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Adam Lunger | University of Dallas |
| Matt Davis | Southern Maine Community College |
| Matt Belonick | Unity College |
| Mike Hasson | University of Dallas |
| Lorenza Stephens | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Ryan Howes | Unity College |
| Jered Lee | University of Dallas |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Ben Maier | Rochester College |
| Jim Woodbury | NHTI |
| Alex Flores | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Tim Haiar | Presentation College |
| Nick Shown | Unity College |
| Stuart Brown | University of Dallas |
| Gerardo Mejia | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Nick Becker | Presentation College |
| Chris Hall | Rochester College |
2005
All-Americans
| Evan Ormand | Presentation College |
| Chris Barker | NHTI |
| Adam Lunger | University of Dallas |
| Scottie Maragon | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Andrew Mack | Southern Maine Community College |
| Brandon Boyle | NHTI |
| Kyle Navarro | William Jessup University |
| Nick Becker | Presentation College |
| Aaron Reyes | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Jered Lee | University of Dallas |
| Ryan Chapernich | William Jessup University |
2004
First Team All-Americans
| Lupe Gonzalez | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Patrick Shaw | Southern Maine Community College |
| Nick Squires | NHTI |
| David Turpin | Bluefield College |
| David Chacon | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Josh Porter | Rochester College |
| Chris Barker | NHTI |
| Chris McCall | Bluefield College |
| Matt Belonick | Unity College |
| Ammon Piatt | Southern Virginia University |
| Ryan Kubly | Taylor University - Ft. Wayne |
| Benny Burrell | Bluefield College |
| Zak Turner | LaGrange College |
| Cliff Jean-Baptiste | Columbia Union College |
| Chase Caldwell | Southern Virginia University |
Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Tetteh Nettey | Columbia Union College |
| Jon Snell | Taylor University - Ft. Wayne |
| Ryan Chepernich | William Jessup University |
| Jimmy Kingsley | William Jessup University |
| Andy Adams | William Jessup University |
| Onel Nacius | Bluefield College |
| Jaimito Valencia | Bluefield College |
| Malek Bekka | UT-Tyler |
| Apollo Turnbow | UT-Tyler |
| Kojo Cole-Kesse | LaGrange College |
| Patrick Kaney | LaGrange College |
| Matt Hill | LaGrange College |
| Chris Slaughter | LaGrange College |
| Eric Lowe | Southern Virginia University |
| Greg McClain | Southern Virginia University |
| Dominic Cook | Southern Maine Community College |
| Chris Zito | Rochester College |
| Andy Barth | Rochester College |
| Lunguanga Shungu | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| Richie Armour | Robert Morris University - Lake County |
| John Ongala | Green Mountain College |
| Brett Foster | Green Mountain College |
| Matthew Rominger | Green Mountain College |
| William Vargo | Paul Smith's College |
*If you have any additional information to add to the archives please contact the USCAA National Office @ 757-798-9536.